Fireshift / Study / Clean setups

What 75 clean Google Ads conversion setups do that 811 others don't

By the Fireshift team · Scanned 5 Nov 2026 · Published 16 Nov 2026 · 886 sites with a readable Google Ads conversion, of 1,727 in the study · Public tags only

TL;DR. On 5 Nov 2026 we read the public tags of 886 sites with Google Ads conversions. 75 (8.5%) were clean: grade A and zero findings. 36 of the 75 (48.0%) send a value with every Ads conversion, against 23 of the other 811 (2.8%). They also count less: a median of 2 Ads conversions, against 4. Enhanced conversions, Consent Mode and a cookie banner were about as common on both sides. We saw the containers, not the Ads accounts, so primary vs secondary is unknown.

75of 886 Ads sites had zero findings
48.0%of clean sites value every Ads conversion (2.8% of the rest)
2 vs 4median Ads conversions, clean vs rest
201of 325 grade-A sites send no value at all

What counts as a clean setup?

We call a setup clean when the free scan gives it grade A and finds nothing. On those 75 sites none of this showed up: an Ads conversion on every page or on a plain view of a page that isn't a success page; a conversion on login; GA4 page views as a key event; an Ads conversion on a button or link; the same conversion set up twice; more than 8 live Ads conversions; no value on any Ads conversion; two or more GA4 properties.

Grade A alone is not the same thing. 325 of 886 sites got an A (B 288, C 168, D 81, F 24 for the other grades), and 250 of the 325 still had a finding.

What do the 75 do differently?

Clean setups vs the other 811 sites, public tags read 5 Nov 2026. Wilson 95% intervals.
HabitClean (n=75)95% intervalThe rest (n=811)95% intervalIntervals apart?
A value on every Ads conversion48.0% 36 of 7537.1 to 59.1%2.8% 23 of 8111.9 to 4.2%yes
1 to 3 Ads conversions66.7% 50 of 7555.4 to 76.3%42.8% 347 of 81139.4 to 46.2%yes
Exactly 1 Ads conversion30.7% 23 of 7521.4 to 41.8%18.7% 152 of 81116.2 to 21.6%no
Median number of Ads conversions24

Two habits stand out. They price what they count: about half send a value with every Ads conversion, against fewer than 3 in 100 of the rest. They count less: two thirds run 1 to 3 Ads conversions.

Part of this is built into the test. A clean site sends a value on at least one conversion and runs 8 or fewer, or it would have a finding. A value on every conversion is not part of the test. That one is a choice, and 48.0% of the clean sites make it. Counted per Ads conversion instead of per site, the gap holds: 137 of 213 conversions on clean sites carry a value (64.3%), against 750 of 5,531 on the rest (13.6%).

What doesn't separate them?

HabitClean (n=75)95% intervalThe rest (n=811)95% intervalIntervals apart?
Enhanced conversions on in a tag42.7% 32 of 7532.1 to 53.9%38.8% 315 of 81135.5 to 42.2%no
Consent Mode signal61.3% 46 of 7550 to 71.5%69.2% 561 of 81165.9 to 72.3%no
Cookie banner (CMP) found72.0% 54 of 7561 to 80.9%72.4% 587 of 81169.2 to 75.3%no
Exactly one GA4 property60.0% 45 of 7548.7 to 70.3%65.1% 528 of 81161.8 to 68.3%no
Server-side tagging signal24.0% 18 of 7515.8 to 34.8%15.3% 124 of 81113 to 17.9%no

Enhanced conversions, Consent Mode, a cookie banner and a single GA4 property are about as common on both sides. They do other jobs: enhanced conversions match conversions to ad clicks, Consent Mode waits for consent. Turning them on does not change what you count. A site can run all of them and still fire its main conversion on a button. Server-side tagging shows on more clean sites, but the intervals touch, so we don't count it as a habit.

Several setup guides we read on 16 Nov recommend enhanced conversions and server-side tagging for a good setup. Both are worth having, but in this data neither is what sets a clean setup apart. What you count and what each count is worth comes first.

What keeps grade-A sites from being clean?

250 grade-A sites had at least one finding. A site can have more than one, so the rows overlap.

201 of the 250 have one finding and only one: no value on any Ads conversion. For them, the step from good to clean is one field per conversion: a rough value that ranks a demo above a whitepaper download. In Google Ads, that value is what value-based bidding learns from.

The checklist to copy

  1. One Ads conversion per real step. Demo booked, trial started, paid. Most clean sites run 1 to 3.
  2. Fire on success. A thank-you page matched by its exact path, or the form's success event. Not the button (click conversions), not the demo page view (page-view rules).
  3. A value on each one. A rough one is fine (values for lead gen).
  4. One tag per conversion. No second copy in another container or in the page code (duplicate conversions).
  5. Nothing on login or on every page (login and trial, every page).
  6. One GA4 property, and page_view not marked as a key event (GA4 key events).
  7. Then set primary actions in Google Ads (Google Ads Help: primary and secondary actions, our primary vs secondary guide).

How do I check mine?

  1. Run the free scan on your domain. It runs the same checks as this study.
  2. Grade A with zero findings puts you with the 75. Anything else is listed with the tag and trigger behind it.
  3. For the value check by hand: in GTM, open each Google Ads Conversion Tracking tag and look at the Conversion Value field. Empty on any tag means that conversion has no value in the tag.
  4. Check the account side yourself: Goals, Conversions, Summary. Is each action Primary or Secondary, and does it have a default value? We can't see this.

Or go through the 9-check audit by hand.

What can't we see from outside?

  • Primary or secondary. That is set in the Ads account. A clean container can still bid on the wrong action.
  • Values set in Google Ads. A default value set in the account doesn't show in the tag. Some of the other 811 may set values there, so the 2.8% is a floor.
  • Whether it fires today. This is a static read of public containers, not a test lead. A renamed dataLayer event can break a clean setup without any sign in the tags.
  • Pages we didn't read. We read the homepage, /pricing, /signup and /demo. A tag that only loads on a thank-you page doesn't show.
  • Cause. These are shares of what we saw. A clean site may also have a better agency or a simpler funnel. The sample is not random.

Method

Static HTTP read of the homepage, /pricing, /signup and /demo (robots.txt respected) and the public googletagmanager.com containers of 1,727 sites on 5 Nov 2026. Base: the 886 with a readable Google Ads conversion. Clean: grade A and zero findings in the free scan's rules. Counts come from the raw rows by script and a separate second-check script, both run again on 16 Nov with the same result. No forms, logins or bot evasion. No site is named. Full rules: method. All-site results: the study.

Updated 16 Nov 2026: first published.

Would your setup pass with zero findings?

The free scan runs the same checks in seconds. Public data only.

Scan my site

See a sample reportOr have us fix it: Fix Sprint, €1,500

Related: the full 1,727-site study · B2B SaaS sites · 9-check audit · all guides

FAQ

What does a good Google Ads conversion setup look like?

A few conversions that fire on real success, each with a value. Of the 75 clean setups we read on 5 Nov 2026, the median ran 2 Ads conversions and 48.0% sent a value with every one.

Do enhanced conversions make conversion tracking clean?

No. 42.7% of the clean setups and 38.8% of the rest had enhanced conversions on. They help match conversions to clicks. They don't change what you count.